Recent studies cast doubt on the value added of international trade agreements and institutions. Using a new data set that consists of about 35,000 observations on the trade of fifty-four nations between 1919 and 1938, we examine whether this skepticism also applies to the infamous interwar trade blocs. Traditional historical accounts attribute to them a large drop in international trade and a rise in the political tensions that would later erupt in World War II. In this study, we show that no bloc raised trade among its members as a whole or decreased trade between members and nonmembers. However, our findings are not wholly consistent with the skepticism recent studies express. We argue that conflicts of interest among the great powers encouraged the emergence of the bloc system and also gave rise to intrabloc trade shifts consistent with the political interests of their great-power hubs. The political-military alliances these conflicts created also reduced trade between their signatories, and we argue more generally that the causal chain runs from politics to trade. As a result, measuring only the effect of agreements and institutions on aggregate trade between their members can generate inaccurate estimates of their value added.
Type Research Article Information International Organization , Volume 67 , Issue 3 , July 2013 , pp. 439 - 467 Copyright © The IO Foundation 2013Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)
Accominotti , Olivier , and Flandreau , Marc . 2008 . Bilateral Treaties and the Most-Favored-Nation Clause: The Myth of Trade Liberalization in the Nineteenth Century . World Politics 60 ( 2 ): 147 –88.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Aldcroft , Derek H. 2001 . The European Economy 1914–2000 . 4th ed. London : Routledge .Google Scholar
Aldcroft , Derek H. 2006 . Europe's Third World: The European Periphery in the Interwar Years . Burlington, Vt. : Ashgate .Google Scholar
Anderson , James E. 2010 . The Gravity Model. Working Paper 16576. Cambridge, Mass.: National Bureau of Economic Research . Available at ⟨http://www.nber.org/papers/w16576⟩. Accessed 20 June 2012 .Google Scholar
Bagwell , Kyle , and Staiger , Robert W. . 2002 . The Economics of the World Trading System . Cambridge, Mass. : MIT Press .CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Baier , Scott L. , and Bergstrand , Jeffrey H. . 2007 . Do Free Trade Agreements Actually Increase Members' International Trade? Journal of International Economics 71 ( 1 ): 72 – 95 .CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Barbieri , Katherine . 2005 . The Liberal Illusion: Does Trade Promote Peace? Ann Arbor : University of Michigan Press .Google Scholar
Barbieri , Katherine , Keshk , Omar , and Pollins , Brian . 2008 . Correlates of War Project Trade Data Set Codebook Version 2.01 . Available at ⟨http://correlatesofwar.org⟩. Accessed 30 April 2013 .Google Scholar
Basu , Susanto , and Taylor , Alan M. . 1999 . Business Cycles in International Historical Perspective . Journal of Economic Perspectives 13 ( 2 ): 45 – 68 .CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bertocchi , Graziella , and Canova , Fabio . 2002 . Did Colonization Matter for Growth? An Empirical Exploration into the Historical Causes of Africa's Underdevelopment . European Economic Review 46 ( 10 ): 1851 –71.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Boyce , Robert . 2009 . The Great Interwar Crisis and the Collapse of Globalization . Basingstoke, UK : Palgrave MacMillan .CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Boyce , Robert . 2010 . The Significance of 1931 for British Imperial and International History . Histoire@Politique. Politique, culture, société 11 : 1 – 17 . Available at ⟨http://www.histoire-politique.fr/documents/11/dossier/pdf/HP11_Boyce_pdf_200510.pdf⟩. Accessed 12 June 2011 .Google Scholar
Cain , Peter J. , and Hopkins , Anthony G. . 2001 . British Imperialism: 1688–2000 . 2d ed. London : Longman .Google Scholar
Drummond , Ian M. 1972 . British Economic Policy and the Empire 1919–1939 . London : Routledge .Google Scholar
Eckes , Alfred E. Jr. 1995 . Opening America's Market: US Foreign Trade Policy Since 1776 . Chapel Hill : University of North Carolina Press .Google Scholar
Egger , Peter , and Pfaffermayr , Michael . 2003 . The Proper Panel Econometric Specification of the Gravity Equation: A Three-Way Model with Bilateral Interaction Effects . Empirical Economics 28 ( 3 ): 571 –80.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Eichengreen , Barry . 1992 . Golden Fetters: The Gold Standard and the Great Depression, 1919–39 . New York : Oxford University Press .Google Scholar
Eichengreen , Barry , and Irwin , Douglas A. . 1995 . Trade Blocs, Currency Blocs, and the Reorientation of World Trade in the 1930s . Journal of International Economics 38 ( 1-2 ): 1 – 24 .CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Feinstein , Charles H. , Temin , Peter , and Toniolo , Gianni . 2008 . The World Economy between the World Wars . Oxford, UK : Oxford University Press .CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Feis , Herbert . 1946 . The Future of British Imperial Preferences . Foreign Affairs 24 ( 4 ): 661 –74.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Findlay , Ronald , and O'Rourke , Kevin H. . 2007 . Power and Plenty: Trade, War, and the World Economy in the Second Millennium . Princeton, N.J. : Princeton University Press .CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Flandreau , Marc . 2000 . The Economics and Politics of Monetary Unions: A Reassessment of the Latin Monetary Union, 1865–71 . Financial History Review 7 ( 1 ): 25 – 43 .CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Glickman , David L. 1947 . The British Imperial Preference System . Quarterly Journal of Economics 61 ( 3 ): 439 –70.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Goldstein , Judith L. , Rivers , Douglas , and Tomz , Michael . 2007 . Institutions in International Relations: Understanding the Effects of the GATT and the WTO on World Trade . International Organization 61 ( 1 ): 37 – 67 .CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gowa , Joanne . 1994 . Allies, Adversaries, and International Trade . Princeton, N.J. : Princeton University Press .Google Scholar
Gowa , Joanne , and Kim , Soo Yeon . 2005 . An Exclusive Country Club: The Effects of the GATT on Trade, 1950–94 . World Politics 57 ( 4 ): 453 –78.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gowa , Joanne , and Mansfield , Edward D. . 1993 . Power Politics and International Trade . American Political Science Review 87 ( 2 ): 408 –20.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hehn , Paul N. 2005 . A Low Dishonest Decade: The Great Powers, Eastern Europe, and the Economic Origins of World War II, 1930–1941 . New York : Continuum International Publishing Group .Google Scholar
Hirschman , Albert O. 1945 . National Power and the Structure of Foreign Trade . Berkeley : University of California Press .Google Scholar
Irwin , Douglas A. 1993 . Free Trade and Protection in Nineteenth-Century Britain and France Revisited: A Comment on Nye . Journal of Economic and History 53 ( 1 ): 146 –52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Irwin , Douglas A. , Mavroidis , Petros C. , and Sykes , Alan O. . 2008 . The Genesis of the GATT . New York : Cambridge University Press .CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jacks , David S. 2011 . Defying Gravity: The 1932 Imperial Economic Conference and the Reorientation of Canadian Trade . Available at ⟨http://www.iga.ucdavis.edu/Research/All-UC/conferences/2011-spring/Defying%20gravity_110418.pdf⟩. Accessed 15 May 2012 .CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jaggers , Keith , and Gurr , Ted Robert . 1995 . Tracking Democracy's Third Wave with the Polity III Data . Journal of Peace Research 32 ( 4 ): 469 –82.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
James , Harold . 2001 . The End of Globalization: Lessons from the Great Depression . Cambridge, Mass. : Harvard University Press .Google Scholar
Lampe , Markus . 2009 . Effects of Bilateralism and the MFN Clause on International Trade: Evidence for the Cobden-Chevalier Network, 1860–1875 . Journal of Economic History 69 ( 4 ): 1012 –40.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
League of Nations . Memorandum on International Trade and the Balance of Payments and International Trade Statistics . Geneva : League of Nations .Google Scholar
League of Nations . 1944 . International Currency Experience: Lessons of the Inter-War Period . Geneva : League of Nations .Google Scholar
Leeds , Brett Ashley . 2003 . Do Alliances Deter Aggression? The Influence of Military Alliances on the Initiation of Militarized Interstate Disputes . American Journal of Political Science 47 ( 3 ): 427 –39.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Leeds , Brett Ashley , Ritter , Jeffery M. , Mitchell , Sara McLaughlin , and Long , Andrew G. . 2002 . Alliance Treaty Obligations and Provisions, 1815–1944 . International Interactions 28 : 237 –60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Magee , Christopher S. P. 2008 . New Measures of Trade Creation and Trade Diversion . Journal of International Economics 75 ( 2 ): 349 –62.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Marshall , Monty G. , and Jaggers , Keith . 2010 . Polity IV Project: Political Regime Characteristics and Transitions, 1800–2009. Dataset Users' Manual. College Park: University of Maryland . Available at ⟨http://www.systemicpeace.org/inscr/p4manualv2009.pdf⟩. Accessed 22 February 2010 .Google Scholar
Mathy , Gabriel P. , and Meissner , Christopher M. . 2011 . Trade, Exchange Rate Regimes and Output Co-Movement: Evidence from the Great Depression. Working Paper 16925. Cambridge, Mass.: National Bureau of Economic Research . Available at ⟨http://www.nber.org/papers/w16925⟩. Accessed 8 May 2012 .Google Scholar
McKenzie , Francine . 2002 . Redefining the Bonds of Commonwealth, 1939–1948: The Politics of Preference . New York : Palgrave Macmillan .CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nye , John V. C. 2007 . War, Wine, and Taxes: The Political Economy of Anglo-French Trade, 1689–1900 . Princeton, N.J. : Princeton University Press .CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Officer , Lawrence H. 2009 . Exchange Rates Between the United States Dollar and Forty-one Currencies . Available at ⟨http://www.measuringworth.org/exchangeglobal⟩. Accessed 15 May 2012 .Google Scholar
Overy , Avner . 1989 . The First World War: An Agrarian Interpretation . Oxford, UK : Oxford University Press .Google Scholar
Rogowski , Ronald . 1989 . Commerce and Coalitions: How Trade Affects Domestic Political Alignments . Princeton, N.J. : Princeton University Press .Google Scholar
Rooth , Tim . 1993 . British Protectionism and the International Economy: Overseas Commercial Policy in the 1930s . New York : Cambridge University Press .CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rose , Andrew K. 2004 . Do We Really Know That the WTO Increases Trade? American Economic Review 94 ( 1 ): 98 – 114 .CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Simmons , Beth. A. 1994 . Who Adjusts? Domestic Sources of Foreign Economic Policy during the Interwar Years . Princeton, N.J. : Princeton University Press .CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Statesman's Yearbook: Statistical and Historical Annual of the States of the World . London : Macmillan and Company . Published annually . Also available at ⟨http://www.statesmansyearbook.com⟩.Google Scholar
Steiner , Zara . 2005 . The Lights That Failed: European International History 1919–1933 . New York : Oxford University Press .CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stewart , Robert B. 1937 . Instruments of British Policy in the Sterling Area . Political Science Quarterly 52 ( 2 ): 174 – 207 .CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tomz , Michael , Goldstein , Judith L. , and Rivers , Douglas . 2007 . Do We Really Know That the WTO Increases Trade? Comment . American Economic Review 97 ( 5 ): 2005 –18.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wolf , Nikolaus , and Ritschl , Albrecht O. . 2011 . Endogeneity of Currency Areas and Trade Blocs: Evidence from a Natural Experiment . Kyklos 64 ( 2 ): 291 – 312 .CrossRefGoogle Scholar